Why the White House Is Panicking About Obamacare

Actors. Actresses. NFL football players. Baseball players. Librarians. Mayors. City councilmen. Members of AARP.

The Obama administration is looking far and wide, leaving no stone unturned in a relentless search for… well… for help.

Help with what? Help with getting people to enroll in health insurance plans this fall.

And why is that? Because the administration is facing the very real possibility that its signature piece of legislation may fall flat on its face.

Last month’s announcement that the employer mandate will be delayed for a year and that income verification for people getting subsidies will also be delayed are the latest signs of trouble. The next shoe to drop may be the failure for people to obtain (ObamaCare) insurance — even if it’s free or highly subsidized.

Consider this:

  • About one in every four individuals who are eligible for Medicaid in this country has not bothered to enroll.
  • About one in five employees who are offered employer-provided health insurance turns it down; among workers under 30 years of age, the refusal rate is almost one in three.

Think about that for a moment. Millions of people are turning down (Medicaid) health insurance, even though it’s free! Millions of others are turning down their employers’ offers. Since employees pay about 27% of the cost of their health insurance, on the average, millions of workers are passing up the opportunity to buy health insurance for 27 cents on the dollar.

You almost never read statistics like these in the mainstream media. Why? Because they completely undermine health policy orthodoxy: the belief that health insurance (even Medicaid) is economically very valuable, that it improves health and saves lives, and that the main reason why people don’t have it is that they can’t afford it.

Welcome to the huge disconnect in health reform. On the one hand there are the people who are supposed to benefit from health reform. On the other hand there are the people who talk about it and write about it. I think it’s fair to say these two groups almost never meet.

Study after study has purported to have found that health insurance improves health, saves lives, makes people happier, etc., etc. But these studies almost always ignore two cardinal facts:

  • We have made it increasingly easy in this country for the uninsured to obtain health care after they get sick.
  • We have also made it increasingly easy for people to get health insurance after they get sick.

Both developments reduce the incentive to spend time and money enrolling in a health plan.

I have described before the experience of emergency room care in Dallas:

“At Parkland Memorial Hospital both uninsured and Medicaid patients enter the same emergency room door and see the same doctors. The hospital rooms are the same, the beds are the same and the care is the same. As a result, patients have no reason to fill out the lengthy forms and answer the intrusive questions that Medicaid enrollment so often requires. At Children’s Medical Center, next door to Parkland, a similar exercise takes place. Medicaid, CHIP and uninsured children all enter the same emergency room door; they all see the same doctors and receive the same care.

Interestingly, at both institutions, paid staffers make a heroic effort to enroll people in public programs — working patient by patient, family by family right there in the emergency room. Yet they apparently fail more than half the time! After patients are admitted, staffers go from room to room, continuing with this bureaucratic exercise. But even among those in hospital beds, the failure-to-enroll rate is significant.

Clearly, Medicaid enrollment is important to hospital administrators. It determines how they get paid. Enrollment may also be important to different sets of taxpayers. It means federal taxpayers pay more and Dallas County taxpayers pay less. But aside from the administrative, accounting and financial issues, is there any social reason we should care?

Economics teaches that people reveal these preferences through their actions. If people act as though they are indifferent between being uninsured and being on Medicaid, we may infer — based on this behavior — they are equally well off in both states of the world from their own point of view.”

Against this conclusion, advocates of “behavioral economics” might argue that people don’t know what’s best for them. They have to be “nudged.” Seeing a football star on TV encouraging young men to enroll in a health plan might do the trick. But for the Obama administration that doesn’t solve the problem. People need more than an initial nudge. They have to be nudged every month.

Take Massachusetts. That state cut its uninsurance rate in half. But the main vehicle was Section 125 plans set up by employers. These accounts allow employees to pay their share of the premiums with pre-tax dollars and they are mandatory. Further, for lower-income employees the insurance is highly subsidized by the state. More to the point, under this arrangement, the employee’s contribution is automatically deducted every pay period.

Under ObamaCare, similarly situated individuals are going to be expected to pay a monthly premium the way they pay their utility bills. But with this difference. When people don’t pay their electricity bills, the utility cuts off their electricity. When they don’t play their rent, the landlord throws them out in the street. But when they don’t pay their health insurance premium, what happens then? Not much.

Why is it so important to the administration to have people enroll? If they don’t enroll in Medicaid, I don’t think it matters very much. But if they don’t enroll in private plans sold in health insurance exchanges, it will matter a great deal. Remember, these will be artificial markets in which insurance will be underpriced to the sick and overpriced to the healthy. A lengthy, complicated enrollment process will further discourage those with no health problems.

But if the only people who enroll are those who are sick, the average premium will go through the roof. A death spiral will ensue as ever increasing premiums price more and more buyers out of the market, leaving only those whose expected medical expenses exceed those high premiums.

The bright side of all this is a possible teaching moment. The whole nation may be treated to one vast demonstration of why prices matter.

— John C. Goodman

Article originally appeared here.

  • Five Scary FEMA Camp Facts You Must Know to Survive a Disaster

    Five Scary FEMA Camp Facts You Must Know to Survive a Disaster

    Jeff Anderson

    by Jeff Anderson
    On Jun 27, 2018

    If you plan to rely on government agencies like FEMA when disaster strikes, you’re making a big mistake. Today, Jeff Anderson runs down five scary truths about FEMA’s incompetence — plus one way you can ensure your family is protected.

    An article in Health, Preparedness

  • Protect Yourself From All Sides

    Protect Yourself From All Sides

    Jason Hanson

    by Jason Hanson
    On Jun 26, 2018

    This week’s roundup of must-read articles covers a lot of ground — from avoiding cellphone tracking to survival sanitation to door safety. And that’s not all… Read on to discover how to keep all the protection you need right in your wallet, the most critical step of wildfire prep and what to do when a stranger comes calling.

    An article in Privacy, Health, Preparedness

  • Title: How to Beat the Heat and Avoid Dehydration

    Title: How to Beat the Heat and Avoid Dehydration

    Omar Hamada

    by Omar Hamada
    On Jun 20, 2018

    As a veteran physician for the U.S. Special Forces and a current emergency room doctor, Dr. Omar Hamada knows a thing or two about staying hydrated for your health. Read on below to discover how much water you should be drinking — and the best way to make sure you’re never without.

    An article in Health

  • Five Things to Ditch in a Crisis

    Five Things to Ditch in a Crisis

    4Patriots

    by 4Patriots
    On Apr 27, 2018

    Today, our friends from 4Patriots run down five habits you should ditch in a crisis. You’ll also discover four substitutes to get you over the hump so you can stay alert and ready to take action.

    An article in Health, Off-Grid Survival

  • When It Rains, It POURS

    When It Rains, It POURS

    Jason Hanson

    by Jason Hanson
    On Apr 17, 2018

    This week’s batch of must-read articles looks at the lessons we can all learn from the recent disaster in Kauai — as well as the No. 1 gun accessory to stock for an emergency, whether or not it’s safe to stock up on fish antibiotics for survival and more.

  • Cleaning Without Running Water

    Cleaning Without Running Water

    4Patriots

    by 4Patriots
    On Apr 13, 2018

    Lack of water contributes to the spread of infectious diseases because you’re unable to maintain basic cleanliness and hygiene. This article runs down five simple steps to help you keep your space clean when you don’t have access to running water. 

  • One SEAL’s Secret to Combatting Chronic Pain

    One SEAL’s Secret to Combatting Chronic Pain

    Cade Courtley

    by Cade Courtley
    On Apr 6, 2018

    Today, Cade Courtley opens up about a personal health struggle and explains why when it comes to preparedness it’s important to take care of your body, too.

    An article in Health

  • Six Steps to Surviving a Chemical Attack

    Six Steps to Surviving a Chemical Attack

    Jason Hanson

    by Jason Hanson
    On Mar 14, 2018

    Chemical weapons can be fatal in incredibly small doses, which is one of the reasons they are so hazardous. If you ever find yourself in the vicinity of a chemical attack, it is critical that you take the following steps to minimize the risks.

  • Do You Know What You're Breathing in Your Home?

    Do You Know What You're Breathing in Your Home?

    4Patriots

    by 4Patriots
    On Mar 9, 2018

    Today, our colleagues over at 4Patriots explain why indoor pollution is worse than outdoor pollution and run down eight ways to keep your home contaminant-free. They even highlight an amazing device that works around the clock to keep you — and your family — safe. ​

    An article in Health, Home Security

  • Basic Trauma Care for Civilians

    Basic Trauma Care for Civilians

    Omar Hamada

    by Omar Hamada
    On Feb 21, 2018

    Today, our resident Special Operations physician, Omar Hamada, reviewed the basics of trauma care for civilians. These skills could come in handy not only after a shooting incident, but also after a car accident or any number of other emergencies.

    An article in Health, Preparedness