Laissez Faire Today

The Laissez Faire Club Daily e-Letter

Regulators Destroying Your Home Appliances

100912_lft1

Ayn Rand’s novella Anthem, the ebook of the week in the Laissez Faire Club, is a story about a government that hates, fears, and bans technology precisely because it wants to keep the people enslaved in a primitive state of being. Preposterous right? Wrong: this is going on every day right in the United States, as the regulatory machine continually wrecks technological advances, past, present, and future. This article discusses two such cases.

The material discussed in this article will matter far more to the quality of your life in the future than the outcome of the president election. And yet we can know with nearly perfect certainty that no candidate will be asked about these issues. They know nothing about it. Neither do the moderators of the debates. It all takes place beneath the surface of American politics within the belly of the bureaucratic monster that actually runs the country and over which elected politicians exercise virtually no control whatsoever.

The regulation in question is “Energy Conservation Standards for Dishwasher, 77 FR 31918.” You can spend the day reading the history’s most obtuse bureaucratese, complete with legislative history and technical detail, along with testimony for and against and the Department of Energy’ final judgement. Or you can just internalize my summary: get used to hand washing your dishes. As of May 2013, dishwasher manufacturers are not going to be allowed to make or sell a machine that works.

The excuse is energy and water conservation of course. The presumption is that consumers and manufacturers have no interest whatsoever in saving energy and water even though everyone pays for both and, for the most part, our usage determines what we pay. The reason that companies and consumers have not adopted the new standards on their own is that they are incompatible with clean dishes.

There’s a pretty good chance that your current dishwasher using 6.5. gallons in a load. In the future, only 5 gallons of water can be used in the course of washing dishes. Maybe the manufacturers can ramp up the intensity of spray? Think again: new “energy efficiency” standards require that they use even less energy. Less energy plus less water equals dirty dishes. Plus, the new energy standards will substantially increase the cost of the appliance, taking it out of the affordability range for elderly people and the poor.

How the heck can the regulators get away with this? You really want to know? Here’s the answer that the Department of Energy cites: “7 U.S.C. 7701–7772 and 7781–7786; 7 CFR 2.22, 2.80, and 371.3. Section 301.75–15 issued under Sec. 204, Title II, Public Law 106–113, 113 Stat. 1501A–293; sections 301.75–15 and 301.75–16 issued under Sec. 203, Title II, Public Law 106–224, 114 Stat. 400 (7 U.S.C. 1421 note).”

So there.

And this is only a few years after the regulators made two additional changes that degrade the value of the dishwasher. They required that dishwasher soap stop using phosphates, and hence the soap scum stays on the dishes and doesn’t get whisked away by this natural chemical. The only real way to get dishes clean in many water environments is to add your own. Plus, with the default setting on hot water heaters at a tepid 120 degrees, the water isn’t hot enough to really clean, unless you have taken the time to hack your heater.

The latest blow to the dishwasher means its near or final death. It will look like the old-fashioned kind. It will take up space in your kitchen. It will have lots of lights and look pretty. But it won’t do a damn thing to actually clean your dishes. Such regulations are never reversed. That means that future generations will never know of a time when you could stick a bunch of dishes in a box and have them come out clean. If you want clean, you will be filling sinks again.

Further, as the amazing Sofie Miller of the George Washington University Regulatory Center testified, this regulation is also an assault on human dignity because it denies us choice in the matter. The central planners know what is best for us and they are going to give it to us good and hard.

I wouldn’t even know about this regulation — and no one would — but for her incredible activism on behalf of human freedom. She is like one tiny David with a slingshot vs. the whole regulatory Goliath of the modern nation state.

In her public comment against this crazy ruling, she pointed out that the proposed savings from the ruling as seen in the models posit a time period well beyond the life of most all dishwashers. She concludes that 84% of consumer will receive no benefit at all from these changes.

What’s more, as people shift from dishwashers to hand washing dishes, there are huge costs to consider. “Thousands of Americans will spend time washing dishes by hand as the price of dishwashers increases,” she writes. “The value of time reallocated to washing dishes by hand totals between $241.4 million and $963.6 million, or almost $1 billion, even at a very conservative estimate. The cost of this time, which will most likely be borne by low-income and elderly Americans on fixed incomes, was not taken into account in the Department’s analysis of the direct final rule.”

As you continue to ponder the implications of a government that is directly targeting your domestic quality of life for destruction, consider this parallel legislation: “Energy Conservation Standards for Residential Clothes Washers FR 77 32308.” This one won’t go into effect until March 7, 2015. So you have two and half years of somewhat clean clothes. After that, it’s pigpen.

It took me hours to dig through the details of this regulation that has been batted around since 2008, but here is the upshot.

Washing machine will become “Washington machines,” useless and heavy steel squares that are more expensive than their predecessor that actually washed clothes. Built by government dictate, Washington machines can’t use much more energy than a wristwatch. Amazing. Infuriating.

Back when washing machines were just introduced, half the American population heralded them as the great key to “liberation from drudgery.” And here they are being destroyed with no public debate whatsoever. The politicians don’t even know anything about it. The media doesn’t care.

I was intrigued to find that one poor soul actually did take seriously the Department of Energy’s invitation for public comment. The comment (view here) was from a woman named Ann Grigorian from Yorktown, Virginia. She pointed out that her washing machine doesn’t work well now and that she expects that the regulations will be worse.

“I have been doing laundry for well over 30 years,” she wrote. “I do not need a babysitter to determine for me how much water to put in my laundry. To say I can get more water by putting less articles of clothing into the washer is incredulous to me – how wasteful is it to wash three articles of clothing just to have enough water to clean them?”

Poor Ann. She is probably on a no-fly list by now.

These two machines together were the greatest boon to American women in the twentieth century, doing far more for women’s liberation than all the legislation and political activism. They created that greatest gift, free time. They allowed women to emerge as full public citizens, to spend time with their kids instead of slaving with household routines, and created the space in life to cultivated the mind and civilization itself.

The regulators want to drive us back, back, back, imprisoning everyone in life of drudgery so that the “earth” can flourish and the rest of us languish, die, and be buried in soiled clothes. The greatest insult of all: this is likely the first and probably the last article you will read on this topic.

Jeffrey Tucker

  • Pingback: Gimme, Gimme, Gimme

  • Pingback: Smiling in Bodrum |

  • http://www.facebook.com/DeliaLopezforcongress Delia Lopez ForCongress

    I wrote a blog post on this over a year ago. In 1996 Consumer Reports Mag. listed several reasonable priced machines that were rated excellent. Now none are rated excellent. I had a tenant complaining her brand new dishwasher did not work. It was tested and worked perfectly except for not getting dishes clean.

  • waimeajim

    Buy one of those garden hose shutoff valves and install it between the cold water outlet and the hose of the washer. No more switching hoses.

    Also, paint the valve position indicator with nail polish to show if it’s open or closed and make a label indicating the open/on position; otherwise all your clothes will be done in HOT water.

  • waimeajim

    I have found that dishwashing soap mixed with water kills most insects. Just mix it in a spray bottle and shoot it on the offending insect. It kills them instantly. I even use it to get rid of ant mounds in the back yard; I pour a gallon of the solution on the mound after I have disturbed it. Works like a nuclear weapon on ants.

  • waimeajim

    Make a hybrid dishwasher powered by a 3,500 PSI water jet machine. Dishes done in 2 minutes

  • waimeajim

    We would be better served if all the Federal Office Buildings in Washington DC have all their water removed, and hand sanitizer used to wash their hands.
    There would be no need for Congress, the Courts, and even the President to bathe after their workouts. What they do stinks to high hell anyway.
    If they have to piss or shit, they can do it at home, or outhouses will be installed to replace them. What would the Founding Fathers do…. Deal with it.

  • disqus_m0bp22JWL8

    Carole, this is copied and pasted from the Odoban website:
    “Q. Does OdoBan Odor Eliminator eliminate dust mites?

    No. It is not on the label, and OdoBan Odor Eliminator may not be used in a manner inconsistent with its labeling.”
    So, if you want (from your comment) ” to get rid of any dust mits that may be around. ” I suggest that you take what may be Jeffrey’s next suggestion…mix equal parts TSP with DDT and add that to your laundry detergent…just wait for him to recommend it, don’t blame it on me since I’m trying to employ sarcasm here.
    Oh, Jeffrey, Jeffrey, Jeffrey…It must be fun to be able to write, in the way that Faux nuese seems to, whatever you want about the eveils of big gubmint, and especially the EPA ! I look forward to the day that you do some real research into your ideas and write honestly on the results…for instance, sir, TSP does really muck up lakes and streams, even if the lack of it makes your starched collars a bit harder to clean in your non-hacked Washington Machines.
    (At least I am relieved that you don’t refer to yourself in the third person plural as Mr Gibson did so much of the time. It was really hard to read his writing, especially when he would only refer to himself in the singular person when he was quoting what he had said to someone in an airport or somewhere, and then switch back immediately to the thrird person. I wish him, or them, well !) (And to you, too, but please get someone to do some real research into your complaints about restrictions on chemicals that may harm the environment..Much of the harm you seem to believe is ficticious many others in the sciences actually do see as harmful. But real research might take some of the fun out of your writing.)
    Long time paid up subscriber to the
    Agora Financial Reserve
    and recent paid up subscriber to Laissez-Faire Books
    H

  • Visitor

    Hey…I’ve always washed everything on cold because I can’t be bothered to sort anyway…clothes seem clean to me.

  • Visitor

    Do your clothes smell like vinegar?

  • Keith Lofstrom

    How much energy and water would we save by shutting down the power lines and water mains going inside the Washington beltway?

  • Pingback: Smiling in Bodrum

  • Pingback: Smiling in Bodrum | The Libertarian Alliance: BLOG

  • Tina In Ashburn

    Thanks for the ideas about turning off the cold water, or switching the cold and hot!

    And YES, I use vinegar as my rinse agent. Waxy fabric ‘softeners’ only wax up the appliances, the clothes, the septic system or your city water treatment plant. Whereas vinegar actually assists in getting out the soap, softening the water, also has anti-fungal, anti-bacterial, and antiseptic properties.
    The manufacturers hate waxy fabric softeners such as Downy and advise you not to use them to lengthen the life of the appliances.

    • Carole Wood

      Hmmm, I never used to use fabric softeners, just started this year, helps keep my shirts from turning into barbi dall shirts. Hadn’t heard that about waxy film. Have you heard of OdoBan? It is sold in Home Depot. It kills EVERYTHING, and has a WONDERFUL scent. It even kills MRSA. It comes in a gallon jug, and sometimes it has a medium sized spray bottlee attached. But if not, get a spray bottle, dilute it and use it. I guarantee you will love it. I wash sheets with a capful – to get rid of any dust mits that may be around. Try it. A friend of mine turned me on to this in February. I love it. I use it in my bathrooms, any place I want to sterilize.

  • http://bastiatscorner.blogspot.com Daniel

    Excellent work as always. I especially enjoyed the concept of Washington Machines – perfect!

  • http://bealfurnitureandtoolworks.com Nathan

    About every third load I wash all my whites twice, I turn off the cold water inlet, run a hot load with soap, then put vinegar in the cold rinse, then I wash them again with the water at the same temperate and add baking soda to the hot water, then allow the baking soda to rinse out in the cold rinse. I have to remember though to turn the cold water back on after it fills, since the machine will sit there all day trying to fill the tub with cold rinse water.

    • Carole Wood

      Nathan, Have you tried the BOXED OXICLEAN? I’m really fussy about whites, and I put a slightly overfilled cup of OxiClean with a good cup of bleach and use Costcos Kirkland soap… white come out brilliant white. Oxiclean has baking soda in it already. Would see to make your ‘whites’ day much easier. BTW, I’m a Tea Party Conservative…. would buy Mikes stuff also. I have 15 yr old top loader and will NEVER go to the front loader. They don’t get your clothes as clean.

  • cookboy

    Tina in Ashburn, reverse the hot and cold water connections on your machines.

    • mik

      That is too easy! makes somuch sense. Thx!

  • http://www.fashionablefoods.net Uttpal K

    Keep up the fight Jeffrey. You will get all support you need across the mases.

  • http://MikeZentz.com Mike Zentz

    Perhaps we need a “getting around regulations” agorist catalog. This could even become a great market for practicing agorists. Design and build custom machines for consumers that ignore regulations. Should be easy enough as 3d printers keep falling in price.

    Maybe I’ll make a living selling unauthorized custom washing machines, dishwashers, and showerheads without paying taxes.

    • Jesse

      I would buy! Do it, Mike. Do it for the rest of us who want to live free of regulations and jackboots. :)

  • Tina In Ashburn

    Great article Jeffrey!!

    This is so true – appliances are getting worse and worse.
    Did you know about slow cookers/crock pots? Yep they wrecked those too.
    To slow cook, these need to run at about 120 degrees. But because of food safety concerns, they have made the manufacturers run these at no less than 167 degrees – so the food will cook hotter. What this means is if you follow the directions for an 8-hr recipe, the meat will be shoe leather. It just doesn’t work.
    If you need a new one, don’t buy new, find a used one.

    I suppose you made fun of toilets in another article?

    They ruined washing machines a long time ago. Try to find a washer with a hot rinse cycle, doesn’t exist. So the soap goes in, but isn’t rinsed out.
    You have to work at finding one with a warm rinse cycle – those are disappearing too.
    Already washer-owners complain about moldy washers [no hot water does that] and gray clothes…uh, cold water washing does NOT clean your clothes.
    On top of that, because of the cold water craze, powdered detergents are disappearing – the liquid laundry is far less effective.

    I add HOT water through the soap dispenser because I also understand that even the warm setting is so tepid as to be hardly warm enough to be worth it.

    Infuriating. We really depend on washing machines – as far as the dish washer, I use it now to rinse my dishes and drip dry them after I wash em anyway. We had one of the first back in the 50s, lousy back then, not much better today…they have never really worked well LOL.

    Oh by the way, why haven’t power tools gone this way? Oh…you see the stuff that MEN use haven’t been fooled with like this.

    • Carole Wood

      Hi Tina, I’m with you. But somebody gave me a great tip on slow cooking that I’ve been using with WONDERFUL results for past 6 yrs. Put a can of beer in your slow cooker with everything else. The alcohol cooks off, you don’t taste it at all, but THE HOPS in the beer break down the meat and make it FORK TENDER. I cook a 5-6 lb. roast for about 10 hrs. Works every time.

    • Carole Wood

      Hi again Tina, Well, my dryer is about 17 years old and squeels like a dying rabbit for the first 1 minute. Guess I’ll go ahead and order a new dryer before I can’t either afford it or even get one. (I like the gas dryers). This is exactly why ALL OF US need to make sure we remove Obummer from office. Make sure your neighbors are voting, and have a ride to the polls. This is the most important election of this country’s history.

  • Cory

    Keep fighting the good fight, Jeffrey. I for one am hoarding replacement parts for my maytag washer and dryer. Back in the USSA…