Laissez Faire Today

The Laissez Faire Club Daily e-Letter

Death by Regulation

I had previously heard nothing about the tragic and remarkable case of Andrew Wordes of Roswell, Ga., who set his house on fire and blew it and himself up as police arrived to evict him from his foreclosed-upon home. It was Agora’s 5 Min. Forecast that alerted me to the case, and this report remains one of not too many mentions in Google’s news feed.

So I got curious about this case, read some of the background, heard an interview with Andrew and read all the tributes at his memorial service and now I realize he was like all of us living under the despotism of our time. He resisted and resisted as long as he could. But rather than finally complying, he decided that a life that is not his own is not worth living.

It is a dramatic and deeply sad story that should raise alarms about the least-talked-about cost of a state-run society: the demoralization that sets in when we do not control our own lives. (I’m grateful to Glenn Horowitz for his careful reconstruction of the timeline of events.)

The whole ordeal began only a few years ago, when Wordes began to keep chickens in his backyard. His property was on 1 acre, but it was surrounded by secluded woods. He loved the birds, sold and gave away eggs to people and enjoyed showing kids the animals. He was also very good at this job, and being something of a free spirit, he chose to make something he loved his profession.

The city objected and came after him. In 2008, the zoning department issued a warning about the chickens on his property. This was odd because he was violating no ordinance at all; indeed, the code specifically approved chickens on properties of less than 2 acres. Even the mayor at the time objected to the department’s claim, but the department went ahead anyway. A year later, and with the assistance of former Gov. Roy Barnes, Wordes won in court!

But then look: The city council rewrote the law with no grandfather clause. It forbade more than six chickens on any lot, and specified that all chickens have to be in a permanent enclosure. He had tried to get approval for an enclosure, but because his house was on a flood plain, the city would not issue an approval. In the midst of this controversy, a flood did come to his house, and he had to use a Bobcat to move dirt around to save his house and his chickens.

Sure enough, the city then issued two citations for moving dirt without a permit and having illegal, unrestrained chickens. Then, the city refused to submit to FEMA (Federal Emergency Management Agency) his request for reconstruction funds after this storm (individuals on their own cannot get money of this sort). Next, the city contacted his mortgage holder, who was a friend and who had carried his mortgage for 16 years, and pressured her to sell the mortgage to stay out of legal trouble.

Do you get the sense from this that Mr. Wordes was being targeted? Absolutely. And he knew it, too. The Roswell Police Department pulled him over constantly and issued as many tickets as possible for whatever reason, tangling him in more difficulties. Police cars would wait in front of his house and follow him. And when he didn’t cough up enough money (he was nearly bankrupt after all this), they would book him and throw him in jail. This happened on several occasions. Meanwhile, the city itself filed several more suits against him.

It gets worse. The city planners came up with a “Roswell 2030 Plan” that posited a parks area exactly where his home was. Hearing of this, Wordes offered to sell his home to the city, but the city refused. They clearly planned to drive him out of it with this legal barrage. It didn’t matter that Wordes won every legal challenge or managed to get the suits thrown out in court — that only made the city angrier. Eventually, the city managed to a get probated sentence, setting up a tripwire that would eventually destroy his livelihood.

He posted on his Facebook account that he was going to be a attending a political event. While he was gone, his chickens were poisoned. Also poisoned were the baby turkeys, 10 of which were actually owned by the mayor, who was a friend. At this point, he had lost his means of support. While panicked about what to do, he missed a probation check-in. He was ordered to serve the remainder of his probated sentence in jail for 99 days.

While in jail, his home was ransacked and looted. Of course, the police did nothing. In fact, they probably approved it. Also while in jail, the new mortgage holder foreclosed on his home. His entire life was now in shambles.

The final episode came on March 26 this year. The police had come for the final eviction. Wordes locked himself in the house for several hours. He then came out and told all authorities to step far away from the house. He lit a match, and the gasoline he had doused all over the house created a gigantic explosion. Wordes’ own body was charred beyond recognition.

Maybe you think that Wordes was some sort of freak who couldn’t somehow adjust to normal life with neighbors. Well, it turns out that he was just about the greatest neighbor one could ever have. At his final service, person after person testified how he would come to anyone’s aid at a moment’s notice, how he fixed things and gave away eggs and was incredibly generous to everyone around him. I listened to an interview with him and found him extremely well-spoken and intelligent.

I tell you, if you can listen to this interview without tears welling up, you have no heart. This man was the heart and soul of what made this a great country. The law hounded and hounded him, mainly because some bureaucrats had made a plan that excluded his home. They carried out that plan. He became an enemy of the state. Demoralized and beaten down, he finally had no way out. He ended his life.

Note, too, that he had the support of the high-ranking members of the political class, including the current mayor and a former governor. Bear in mind what this signifies: The political class is not really running things. As I’ve written many times, the political class is only the veneer of the state; it is not the state itself. The state is the permanent bureaucratic structures, those untouched by elections. These institutions make up the real ruling apparatus of government.

It is hard to say that Wordes made the right decision. But it was a courageous one — at least I think it was. It is a difficult moral choice, isn’t it? When the police come to take all you have and are determined to cut out your heart and soul and reduce your life to nothing but a sack of bones and muscle, without the right to choose to do what you love — and you really see no way out — do you really have a life? Wordes decided no.

The rest of us need to think hard about this case, and perhaps you can also spare a few thoughts in memory of his good life, and even a prayer for his immortal soul. May we all long to live in a society in which such people can thrive and enjoy “life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.”

  • Pingback: A perfect picture of how increasing government regulation destroys our ability to be stewards before God.

  • Pingback: Attack the System » Blog Archive » Weekend News Update May 4-6, 2012

  • amenra

    America is quite fond of using violence to bring about their sham democracy to other countries. Why is it hard for the citizens to see that it will take violence to correct the graft masquerading as a government in the good old U.S.A? Was it not violence that destroyed the life force of this man? America has always been a violent nation and now that it comes to standing up to the government the citizens want to pretend that we are all pacifists. What a bunch of hogwash. It is long passed the time we overturn this system.

  • KTL

    Until the powers that be are made to pay(personally) they will run rampant. The jews bulldozed the houses of suspected terrorist during the mass campaign of suicide bombers and things got quiet. If we let these Nazi’s go on living without paying for their direct attack on our rights than things will remain just as they want them.

  • http://www.newatlantean.com Robert Hewes

    Martin Seligman and Steve Maier showed back in 1967 that if you remove an animal’s ability to control its environment it rapidly gives up hope. This “learned helplessness” is thought to be a significant cause of major depression and other mental illness. It sure looks like that’s what happened to Mr. Wordes.

    And Herold, I, too, thought of the Battle of Athens as I read this story.

    And Jane, you’re an idiot. Ask those rescued from Auschwitz if violence is ever acceptable.

  • Harold

    His other choice was, of course, utilizing his second amendment rights against the police and others who were unlawfully harassing him.

    For which he would have been branded a right wing extremist and condemned by all right thinking people.

    There is a reason why the “Battle of Athens” is not taught in any class on constitutional law.

  • Pingback: » Quick newsy bits and links - Le·gal In·sur·rec·tion

  • Pingback: Chores, Chickens, and the PSA(Police State of America) | Ex Ultra Jordan

  • Pingback: The Daily Eudemon

  • Pamela Jones

    He is not the first American to commit suicide as a result of government harassment. A gentleman in New Hampshire immolated himself at the local courthouse, a gentleman flew his plane into an IRS office in Texas. The last few years in my medical practice I have seen increasing despair and hopelessness.
    Violence is not a solution, but I begin to the question the morality of supporting a corrupt and bloated government with hard-earned tax dollars. When I meet my maker will I be taken to task for my passive complicity with this atrocious government?

  • nc_notary

    I only knew Andrew through facebook and yet he touched me like my real life friends and family. His story and the truth will be told and his memory will live on. RIP Andrew and thank you for being my friend!

  • http://Facebook-PaddlesWebb Paddles Webb

    I am sickened, and yet somewhat gratified, that all this press if finally getting this story out to the public. I tried to help Andrew. As a former broadcaster I made the phone calls to media, sent email to the major networks and attempted to arrange for press coverage. He needed 20/20 or 48 Hours or 60 Minutes, or any of a dozen network investigative news teams to intervene and publicize the torture inflicted on Andrew by the local government. A local government, by the way, which was elected to protect him. Andrew badly needed a few big noisy journalists to bring the hammer down on Roswell … but they did not respond, to me or to Andrew.. One reputable newspaper answered my request for publicity, and interviewed Andrew. ONE.

    Within 1 hour of his death I sent an email to Roswell’s Chief of Police, which was then forwarded to the Commissioners. The response I received from the good Chief would be actionable in a court of law. The untruths he spewed, and the personal information he provided in response, in an effort to make the police look innocent in the events that occured on March 26th, only served to prove how deep the government of Roswell was in this crime.

    A good man is dead, at the hands of the very government that is in place to protect him. Andrew tried to warn all of us … in his words, “If this can happen to me, it can happen to any of you!”

    Now, what are we going to do to bring about justice for Andrew Wordes and restore the inalienable rights guaranteed to US citizens by the Constitution? Remember … it can happen to you too.

  • SAUL

    There is a GOD watching all this and each shall pay for their sins,sad sad all they did to him a good person loved his bird does not suprise me how man can fail man may he rest in peace

    • Rosemarie/OCCUPY MOTHER63

      I absol;utely ADORE your answer and THERE IS A GOD looking over us all and Mr Wordes will be blessed by Gods arms…Namaste My friend <3

  • http://www.EcoReality.org Jan Steinman

    “We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men are created equal. That they are endowed by their creator with certain inalienable rights. That among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. That whenever any form of government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the right of the people to alter or abolish it, and to institute new government.”

    So, why didn’t all his supporters — including the Mayor and Governor — “alter or abolish it?”

    The sheeple need a good waking up. I won’t quote Martin Niemöller, but if you don’t stand up for your neighbour, who’s gonna stand up for you when you need it?

  • Pingback: Among the leading causes of despair… | The Bovine

  • Pingback: Tips to stock trading » Blog Archive » Despair and the State

  • Pingback: Despair and the State

  • RocketSurgeon

    The voice from my left shoulder says “Take a full chicken truck, park it in the Roswell town square very early one Sunday morning, unhook the trailer and open the back. Then, just drive off.” Expensive, but with enough widespread support . . .

    The voice from my right side says “And nobody else lifted a finger to help the guy? Nobody protested at the town council meetings? Nobody bailed him out? All those who praised him when he was buried did nothing while he lived? Something’s fishy here.” Thus do the voices of passion and reason cancel each other out.

    Too many years in the trenches have caused me to be a natural skeptic, even in the arenae where I am in total agreement. A greater exposition, timeline and fact base would help to elucidate. The principle is easy enough, but accounts in the battle against fascism at any level have to remain rooted in truth or else they become just so much propaganda.

  • B Williams

    There is another side of this story we missed somewhere … First the Mayor of any city acts as the sole director of the staff (bureaucrats) and can direct all and any staff member of the city gov at any time. He is also in a position to terminate any staff member — albeit facing any legal ramifications – he is their legal employer . Note – only the mayor among elected Councillors has this power exercised through Council’s CEO. Note also that the elected council passes and revolks the by-laws and policies the staff are directed to follow. The council and the Mayor also can make the decisions to prosecute or take any legal action – and can pull out once its started if wish. The Mayor’s day of reckoning is at the ballot box – not at the hand of any staff member.
    So it makes me wonder how the staff could continually carry out actions on Andrew against the wishes or orders of the Mayor and the elected council. If the staff dug up an old ordinance then – presto the ordinance could be changed. You would be surprised how fast councils can act when they want to. As a passing note I have tried to get councils to act on certain situations where the public have taken over council land and guess what – you would be amazed how many time councils do not prosecute blatant ordinance offenders — So I must wonder what a good friend the Mayor was to Andrew — //

    • ThePaintedOne

      The City of Roswell is a City Manager form of municipality; the position of Mayor is more a formality. That City Manager, Kay Love, wanted to break him.

  • Barry Obama

    Hope and Change on a fundamental basis. Your government at work. It was Bush’s fault!

    • Mike

      no Barry, its just government in general. almost all government officials are corrupt. it wasn’t just one man that caused all the problems, it was a combined force of government officials that messed everything up.

  • Pingback: Despair and the State « Financial Survival Network

  • Pingback: The Daily Reckoning April 17th | HoweStreet.com

  • Jack

    When a state turns on it’s people, in time the people will turn on the state. The American dream is over.

  • david

    A list of ALL who partipated in EACH event in this sequence should be made and publicly published. And to include their address and telephone number. By ALL i include the clerk who did the filing and the secretary who simply put the papers into the file cabinet and on up the chain of command, the head of each division and their boss. Plus if this story never reached the papers during its evolution it should be so mentioned including publisher and news desk editor.

    I sincerely doubt anyone will do it and also doubt that, should it be done, anything will result, not even a finger wagging. Everyone is too buzy keeping their head down so as not to be noticed. Or hiding in a crowd like the bureaucrats who persecuted him

    So the question is anyone here living within 50 miles of Roswell?

  • Brian Dove

    This story should not end here. The people responsible for this that work for the City of Roswell, GA need to be investigated and brought to Justice for this behavior. If the Mayor defended him, then the Mayor should not who and what was behind all of this, as well as the former Governor.

    Andrew Wordes should not die in vain and as fellow countrymen we should do all we can to fight the criminals that brought about this tragedy. Everyone should contact the Ga Attorney General and demand a full and thorough investigation, and prosecution of all those involved.

    Office of the Attorney General
    40 Capitol Square, SW
    Atlanta, Ga 30334

    Phone: (404) 656-3300
    Fax: (404) 657-8733

    also the Prosecuting Attorney’s Councils office of GA.

    Atlanta (Main)
    104 Marietta Street NW, Suite 400
    Atlanta, Georgia 30303-2743
    404-969-4001 phone
    404-969-0020 fax
    info@pacga.org

  • Pingback: News of the Week: Today is Tax Day | LibertarianChristians.com

  • Pingback: Despair and the State | Laissez-Faire Bookstore

  • Missy

    SPOILER: From the article “It is hard to say that Wordes made the right decision. But it was a courageous one — at least I think it was. It is a difficult moral choice, isn’t it? When the police come to take all you have and are determined to cut out your heart and soul and reduce your life to nothing but a sack of bones and muscle, without the right to choose to do what you love — and you really see no way out — do you really have a life? Wordes decided no.”
    From me:
    What?! Suicide is NEVER a “right decision”; this guy had the courts defending him long enough that he may have been able to appeal the situation. Whether or not, is your life over just because you lost your possessions and 99 days of freedom? Of course not! Shame on the author for even suggesting such a thing.
    And to call it a moral choice… It’s a mortal choice.

    • Kevin

      US Constitution, Amendment 5:

      “nor be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.”

      What they did was un-Constitutional. He had every right to fend for himself against his aggressors. In this case, the aggressors were people of the state. From what I read in this article, they didn’t like what he was doing, so they set out to destroy his life. The destroyed his lively-hood, then took what was left from him. Our ever-increasing police state is in the fact that Obama is not wanting to let go of his position. He is out to destroy America and the US Constitution. It is acts like this that continue to allow it to happen.

  • Pingback: “Chicken man”: another freedom-loving patriot pushed over the edge

  • Wayne Cox

    As a former police officer I can absolutely see this happening. I left the profession, something I believed in early on, after eight years because I was being used as a tool to destroy otherwise very decent people’s lives. We do absolutely live in a police state and this man is but one of many examples happening all too regularly. God bless him.

  • Jacob D Steelman

    The state is an instrument of force and the ultimate excercise of that force always ends in tragedy and death. Make no mistake Wordes knew that ultimate resistance would have resulted in the police shooting him, he instead elected to take his own life.

  • A Country Farmer

    Although I can understand the sentiment that this was a courageous move, as Matt Ridley writes in The Rational Optimist — The world has become better *despite* the chiefs, priests, and thieves of history. I certainly don’t judge what he did, but sometimes we just have to live with the immoral protection racket around us, avoid it as much as possible, and non-violently change it.

    My take away from this story, sad as it is, was that sometimes it’s not worth fighting the government, even in courts. They’re not using their own money to prosecute, and they are never admonished for failed cases. They have all the incentive and even if you win in court, nothing changes. I don’t mean to be fatalistic — the real fight is in the hearts and minds of people — the favors Wordes did for his neighbors. The government will wither away on its own as wealth increases and people coalesce around the better people… like Wordes.

  • John fasolino

    The author , or anyone who knows,should list the names of all the scum who had a hand in destroying this mans life.

  • Maria Folsom

    Right on, Zak!

  • Maria Folsom

    OMG. What a horrid story. This man is truly a martyr. But for the grace of God go I!

  • Zak Young

    A noble sacrifice, but he should have taken some of the pigs out with him.

    • Jane Done

      Yeah, Zak, that’s all we need. You are suggesting murdering police officers as a solution to government restrictions?

      YOU are the problem, not Roswell government. YOU and Chicken Man and every American thinking that violence is EVER an acceptable act.

      Because violence takes away EVERYBODY’S rights. Cops have rights also.

      Did you put your real name on your terrorist threat here?

      • Herbert Muzz

        Oh Jane, what sweet irony in your comment. Haven’t you realized yet that government IS violence? You are quite right that violence takes away rights. That is why we must never have a government (a.k.a. monopoly on violence).
        On the other hand, violence against the government isn’t the answer.