Laissez Faire Today

The Laissez Faire Club Daily e-Letter

Brazil and the Spirit of Liberty

My most surprising findings in Brazil, aside from the amazing fruits that I didn’t know existed because the U.S. government doesn’t think I need them, were the young American kids who have moved here to find economic opportunity. This I had not expected, but now fully understand.

Brazil is a marvelous and massive country where private wealth thrives without embarrassment, where well-protected and healthy familial dynasties form the infrastructure of social and economic life, where technology is popular and beloved by everyone, where the police leave you alone and where Americans can feel right at home.

The world is changing fast. Freedom in America is slipping away so quickly that we are already seeing a wave of young people leaving in search of new opportunities, just as people from the around the world once came to America to live the dream. Brazil is one of many countries benefiting from the generational emigration from the U.S.

Discovering this rattled me more than I might have expected. But the young people themselves are not unhappy, and I can see why. They are valued. They are earning good money doing interesting things. They have access to one of the most beautiful and exotic and friendly places on Earth. They eat well, live well and have rich social lives.

More than anything else, they have the sense of freedom.

Now, you might wonder how it is that people have to leave the “home of the free” to find freedom. Over the last 10 years, something horrible has happened to the United States. The police state has cracked down hard, not so much on “terrorists” or real criminals, but on regular citizens. The news items spill out of my feed on an hourly basis, things that just shock and alarm those who are paying attention.

Maybe it is not so surprising. The U.S. military is larger than most of the world’s militaries combined. We have the largest prison population on the planet, and most are locked up for nonviolent crimes. The political culture focuses more on the need for security than for freedom. Add it all up and you have the perfect recipe for the emergence of a police state.

But most Americans are not entirely conscious of the change. It has been fast, but slow enough not to cause alarm. It hits you only once you leave. This happened to me two years ago when I went to Spain. I could move about and do what I wanted without bumping into authority at every turn. I felt it again in Austria last year. It is not something you can quite put your finger on, just a sense that you are not under constant surveillance in suspicion. You can breathe easily.

It was the same in Sao Paulo, Brazil, a happy and prosperous land of exotic fruits, thriving markets, consumer products that actually work and are not depreciated by regulatory mandates, and polite and warm people.

I received a very generous invitation to be a main speaker at the third conference on Austrian economics sponsored by Mises Brasil, a young organization with a very bright future. It was founded only four years ago. Yet today, it has a gigantic presence in Brazilian intellectual life. The hunger for the intellectual basis of freedom is palpable.

Three hundred or more people were here to listen to lectures and engage in debates on ideas. The audience was a sea of young people, most everyone under 30. They were students, professionals, traders and workers of all sorts, all passionate about freedom and the economic answers provided by the Austrian tradition of Ludwig von Mises, F.A. Hayek and Murray Rothbard.

What most excited them was the classic idea of laissez faire — that is, the idea that society can thrive on its own in the absence of central management and that the government operates as a drain on society. The culture of the group was certainly more intellectual and educational than political. They were invigorated by ideas and given hope by the idea of freedom. Apparently, nothing like this organization existed in Brazil until recently. Now the group’s website is one of the most heavily trafficked in the country.

My hosts were enormously generous with their time, and they knew exactly what I really wanted to do on the first day: see the delights of the open-air markets. I was told they are in the center of town. If you had seen a map of Sao Paulo, you would know just how odd it is even to imagine such a thing. The city seems to be everywhere in sight, everywhere you turn, going on forever. It is like 100 New Yorks.

Driving here is not for the faint of heart. The street layout makes no rational sense at all. I could have been driven the short distance between the hotel and the conference center a hundred times and still not have had the slightest clue about the layout. I was told that it would take at least two years of living here to gain a sense that you really know the place.

Go to a high spot in the center of town and look around on all sides. Everywhere you see a beautiful thing, a world built by millions of human hands. No central plan could have made this. No single mind could have conceived of it. To anyone who is intellectually curious, the obvious questions are how does this place work? How is order achieved? The answer is one that few people in the United States seem to care about today. The miracle is obtained through the coordinating forces of the market itself, of millions of free people interacting in small ways toward their mutual self-betterment. This is the answer that inspires a lifetime of intellectual curiosity.

On the first lunch on my first day, my hosts took me to a place like I had never seen, and they are as unconscious of its significance as Americans would be startled by its very existence. Again, it seemed to be in the center of town. To obtain entry requires extensive security checks. But once you are in, a new world emerges: restaurants, soccer fields, gigantic swimming pools of many varieties and delights as far as the eye can see.

This is a city within a city. But it is entirely private, what Americans would call a “country club,” but of a particularly elaborate type. It is not hidden away in some alcove on the outskirts of town. It is right there in the city for everyone to see — something nonmembers can also take pride in. It is marvelous in every way, a living monument to the possibility of orderly, privately owned anarchist communities.

One thing kept gnawing at me during my entire visit. I kept coming across people who were members of large and extended families with roots very far back in Brazilian history. They were impressive entrepreneurs, but the wealth was more robust than you would find in a place like Silicon Valley. It reminded more of Gilded Age families in the United States, people who carried themselves with grace and confidence born of excellent breeding and material security.

As I thought about it more, the ingredients were unusual by American standards: large and extended families, protected wealth, well-bred youths, a predominantly young population. What was the reason for this? I developed a quick, back-of-the-napkin theory. It had something to do with the inheritance tax. So I asked my hosts, “What are estate taxes like in this country?” The answer came fast: There are none. Some areas charge 3%, maybe 6%, but it is rather easy to escape even those minimal charges.

This contrasts with the United States, where estate taxes can be as high as 35%. We’ve been looting our best families for 100 years. We’ve gouged and smashed the richest generations of American capitalists upon death ever since the Progressive Era. We’ve been living one generation at a time. Time horizons have fallen. Large-scale, privately held capital accumulation has been discouraged, even made illegal. Families have shrunk in size. The population has become ever more aged.

This tax policy has eaten the heart out of the desire of a free people to create dynasties. So our wealthy have to hide. They are encouraged to give their money away to causes, rather than to children. We live one generation to the next. Children are perceived as an economic burden, rather than a path to immortalizing a legacy.

In Brazil, the time horizon extends beyond the single lifetime. And this is what has given rise to the dramatic cultural, social and economic differences between our countries. These dynasties serve as robust intermediating institutions between the individual and the state. We have ever fewer such things in the United States. Maybe this is what accounts for the incoherent sense that this is a freer country than the U.S.

There are other factors, too. The military consumes only a tiny percentage of wealth, and Brazilians dread wars because they know that they will be roped into supporting whatever wacky war the U.S. starts. What’s more, the police are well-known to be as likely to commit as prevent or punish crime, so they are not trusted.. Security is extremely important in Brazil, but everyone knows that it is a private function and not anything anyone would entrust to the state.

The beautiful thing about Mises Brasil as an organization is that it is working to further encourage these instincts and spread an intellectual culture that openly embraces liberty as a model of life itself. They publish books and monographs, hold conferences and spread the liberal tradition far and wide among an idea-hungry generation. This is all about the future, and Mises Brasil is right to have confidence in it.

As I waited in the customs line to enter the U.S. again, we were all shown a film designed to introduce America to new visitors. The film featured kids in ballet class, people riding horses, barn raisings, people water surfing, dances from coast to coast, smiling people of all ages, all against the backdrop of an exciting Coplandesque musical score.. It ended with the Statue of Liberty. It was wholly inspiring, but there was something missing: The government was nowhere to be seen.

How I wish this film were the whole truth about our country. It once was. But the American dream is not about geography; the American dream is an idea that moves like a spirit around the world, landing wherever people are willing to embrace it and confess it as creed. That spirit has landed in Brazil, and it was a great honor to be witness to it.

  • Rafael

    This is a very interesting text. As a Brazilian, my first thoughts were, like many of the others here, “poor Tucker, so naive…”, but then after some wondering I could find the truth of it.

    Yes, the Brazilian state is huge, we pay more taxes than the majority of the peoples of the world and many aspects of or everyday life seem to stress out our lack of liberty all the time. But it is common sense, hardly anyone disagrees, that each and every good or service provided by the state is crap. Police? Crap. Post Office? Lame. Public Transport System? Garbage. People know they can’t count on government and try to live their lives as well as they can without being bothered by it. That is already something, isn’t it?

  • Pingback: My Government is Worse than Yours | Laissez-Faire Bookstore

  • Justo

    I think you had too many “Caipirinhas” when you wrote this.
    When you get sobber think it over again.
    Tax here are Norwegians but services are Somali.
    28.5% is robbed directly from my pay check every month.
    Nearly 50% of the cost of a car here are taxes.
    With the money I pay for a Ford Fusion here I can buy a Porsche Cayenne or a Mercedes Benz in USA. Licensing my car cost me 4% of its price every year.
    Every Brazilian works 4 to 5 months every year only for the taxes, it means we are slaves of the Government nearly half of our economicaly active life..

  • Breno Almeida

    As a Brazilian I am personally offended by this text. Brasil is a country that hold a culture of liberty hate, just have a quick look in the Brasil 1988 constitution, you will have a hard time to find a more socialist piece of legislation.

    Brasil history also show a background of freedom hate.Founding a country using the August Comte motto of “Order and Progress” tell a lot about how much the founders hated freedom.

    Is also strange that Jeffery didn’t notice that Brazilian people don’t carry guns. Not been able to carry a gun basically makes brazillians slaves, specially in high violence country like Brasil.

    How someone can conclude that Brazilian gated community’s are private when federal government regulate even the employee time-clock used by these community’s.

    The Brasil prominent social envy culture is good reason to move your family to a gated citys. In Brasil is not hard to find people who think that robbing rich people is a virtue and the criminal is the victim.

    The part that says brazillian police will leave you alone is so unreal that is almost funny. We do have a full blow police state with check points on the street. And there is not such a thing as freespeech when free speech means you using twitter to warn people about check-points. Also in Brasil you must carry a national ID and you must show it if asked and not even think about offending the cop because you will go direct to the jail. Also in Brasil most of people in the jail are for non-violent crime.

    The interesting thing is people specially middle class generally ask for more police on the streets and more check-points. Brasil is already a police state and people learned to like it.

  • Adolf Schimmer

    I am from Brazil. This book can only be fiction or comedy.The analysis is totally nonsense.

  • http://dnabrasilis.blogspot.com/ Carlos U. Pozzobon

    Considering Mr. Tucker a tourist he a very interesting visitor. But, going beyond the surface, Brazil is the most disastrous project as a nation. The bureaucracy along with the government arrogance is comparable to a communist country, to say the least. The impunity of the political class , the judiciary and high level administration, has no comparison to any other country, except the Nomenklature in Soviet Union. And so go the list. However our economic grow is a real fact, and based on commodities raising prices rather than any strategic development.

  • Victor Oliveira

    Brazil is not a land of freedom starting with the lack of free speech.
    Brazilian constitution essentially treats everything as a concession from the state, from communication to transportation to any basic infrastructure necessity.
    With one of the highest tax rates in the world, probably the most complicated system, and the highest interest rates in the world, Brasil is not a place for the entrepreneur, unless this entrepreneur has ties with government officials.
    Even if the state doesn’t interfere with a particular initiative, it may happen at any moment, it will be arbitrary, and not fair at all.
    Our legal system is probably the slowest in the world, and without punitive damages, our legal system has 10 times (yes, 10 times) the number of law suits in the US!
    If some US citizens are coming here is because US is a great place for doing business and they will go after the money.
    Right now, Brazilian government has spent a lot based on credit, check our internal debt indicators.
    The carefree environment you see when meeting brazilians has nothing to do with freedom or individual liberties.
    Brasil has many things in it’s favor, like the self image myth of being a single mixed race or the unity in language in the entire territory, but freedom is not one of them.
    For entrepreneurs it’s not safe in terms of legal safety, regulations, access to credit, and the list goes on.
    Even as you mention the image of the entrepreneurs you are wrong. Entrepreneurs are largely seen as evil people taking advantage of the average population and exploiting others. It’s a popular myth that if you have become successful it is not because of hard work, it’s exploitation or corruption. Not as job generators, not as examples to be copied or admired as it is largely in the US.
    In the Brazilian novelas, entrepreneurs are evil, doomed to be in jail or dead. And even when they are good, in order to be happy they loose everything before the end of the show.
    That’s it, lending you money to the government pays a lot more than putting it into productive means. Please compare the CDI with the Bovespa index, long or short term!
    10 years ? Yes, it is still better to lend to the government.

    Entrepreneurs in Brasil are entrepreneurs because of a remaining influences of positivism in the 18th and 19th century, including the US founding fathers. We, brazilian entrepreneurs, are essentially stupid. Not free.

  • Jenner

    I am a real estate developer in Brazil. Despite being naive, the article has some interesting points and some commentators were very critic about their own country. It’s not true you have to bribe everyone. The labor laws are essential to protect the weak and legal hiring is nowadays the norm. And the author is right: wealth goes from one generation to another, almost without taxation. I don’t know if this is good, but it hasn’t prevented social mobility, one of the highest in the world. And yes, at the personal level, it’s one of the freest places on Earth. At the business level, it’s somewhere between Zaire and Finland. Not kidding…

    • Justo

      It is not true that State Taxes is only 3 to 6% over heritage.
      In reality it goes up to more than 30%.
      To avoid it, I’ve given my whole patrimony to my sons in life.
      I’ll die the poorest man in earth but the government won’t still a cent from my sons.

      • http://lfb.org Jeffrey Tucker
      • Rafael

        I think Mr. Tucker was referring to what here would be called ITCMD, which is a tax that levies whenever you receive a donation or whenever someone dies and leaves you something by will. The monthly 27,5% of Income Tax (I feel your pain too, bro…), despite its absurdity, was not what was being compared here, I think.

  • Irineu de Carvalho Filho

    You are completely crazy if you think Brazil is a better place for free enterprise than the USA. You have no clue how stupid you look like for writing this article. Brazil is a country where the government – unlike the US – is REALLY involved in everything. From financing of businesses to labor laws and all sorts of regulations. Please get yourself a clue.

  • Claudio

    Articles like that are not only wrong. They are irresponsible. Brazil is one of the least economicaly free country in the world (please, do your homework!). Corruption makes the entire population hostage of state agents. Regulation is so absurd that it is virtually impossible to run a store without bribing the inspectors. Hiring legaly is also a hell. Our constitution states that the property has a social function. Our civil code states that contracts have social function too. The country is managed in the most centralized way possible. Your text is immensely irresponsible but very useful: it shows how ideology can blind on both sides of the spectrum.

  • Paulo

    Jesus. Mt Tucker, you really have no idea what you are talking about. Go do a little bit of research and try to understand how your comparison is ridiculous. Look at the labor laws in Brazil and see how ‘free’ these are. Look at the agregated taxes, the lack of an free speech guarantee, etc, etc. The few people who do migrate to Brazil are a tiny number compared to the number of Brazilians who still migrate to the US (like me).

    Even your admiration of Brazil’s ‘small military’ is incredibly naive. Brazil can only have such a small military because it knows that the US would intervene in any possible invasion from whatever power.

    Even though I like the folks at mises.org.br they are so, so small that the majority of brazilians wouldn’t even know what they are about.

    Seriously, it has been a while since I’ve read sonmething this bad..

  • http://www.thinkir.co.uk Lucas Freire

    Thanks for looking at the bright side. Of course there’s still a lot of statism, big government, progressivism and centralisation left in the country. São Paulo is a prosperous place, but the same cannot be claimed for other places. But again, there’s the bright side. In spite of the problems, we can still hope that this ‘bright side’ will prevail, and Mises Brazil plus a few other organisations are crucial in this process.

  • Guilherme

    I’ve never read so much stupidity about Brazil, ever! Our taxes are asfixiating. We have less and less medium class workers. PT politicians, with their projetc of eternal power, are encouraging people not to study, and therefore remain stupid and subject to manipulations of all kinds, specially populists ones. We are living a real estate boom based on easy credit, without people caring if they’re able to pay it back in the future. This ease of credit is also encouraging reckless consuming, and thus generating inflation. Of course the politicians are covering the real inflation rate by manipulating the “official” index. For instance, a reosanable tree bedroom apartment, fairly located in São Paulo doesn’t come for less than R$ 1 million, with only one parking space. Good private schools for our kids – since public schools are pure rubbish, regardless the over 40% GDP tax rate we have – doesn’t come for less then R$ 1,200.00/month, plus enrollment fees and other costs. Add to that countless expenses brazilians have on a daily basis. Brazil is a shitty country (I’m brazilian, born and resident till today), full of corruption and disrespect for citizens, where the rule is to take advantage of everything and everyone at every occasion of life, with minimun effort and no moral code at all.

    • http://lfb.org Jeffrey Tucker

      I don’t doubt that all of this is true. My ONLY purpose in writing this was to draw attention to the irony that in at least two respects, Brazil, as bad as things are, is in a better position than the U.S.

      • Guilherme

        Thank you for the reply, and I also would like to apologize for the furiosity of my first manifestation. I trust you were well intentioned on providing a diverse point of view, but being a brazilian and watching what the politicians have benn doing to us is abnoxious. The bottom line is, here in Brazil, social mobility ir poor. Rich families get richer mostly by marrying within, and also by engaging in corruption to maintain their wealth and status. Education is a long forgotten thing around here, I mean, public good and universal education, as it should be. My life cost here is greater than most metropolis in the world.
        With all this social, economic and political obstacles, my guess is that we’re not at all free. And since the greater mass of people is unneducated, ignorant and easily manipulated by politicians (most of them worse than petty criminals), educated and aware people like me suffer from teh feeling of impotence, since we cannot do much for a change to happen.

  • Fabricio

    I’ve never read such a stupid words about Brazil. I am brazillian and by reading this article, I can ensure that this book is in of the worst ever written. Don’t buy it! I tried to bring my money overseas. Is this writer being serious???

  • http://kauejones.com Kauê Jones

    The site in the post is wrong. The correct address is “mises.org.br”

    Cheers,
    Jones.