Laissez Faire Today

The Laissez Faire Club Daily e-Letter

Are You the Next Prisoner?

The United States is home to a gigantic socialist sector, larger and with a greater reach than any in the world, and it is fed by tax dollars and managed entirely by the government. Strangely, the opponents of socialized medicine and socialized industry don’t complain about it. In fact, all throughout the 1980s and 1990s, they urged its expansion.

It is called the prison system. It’s a fairly new system, but the cruelties of similar systems are so famed throughout history that they are spoken of by the Psalmist: “For the Lord hears the needy and does not despise his own people who are prisoners.”

The presumption in the Psalms is that prisoners are despised, ignored, forgotten, dismissed — and they are in our country, where this topic is not even on the list in the mainstream debate.

It’s stunning when you think about it. The “land of the free” is home to the world’s largest prison population. Americans constitute 5% of the world’s population, yet one-quarter of the entire world’s inmates are in the U.S. The ratio of the prison population to the general population is higher in than any other nation in the world. Russia is second. China is third.

If the jailed lived in one place, the 2.3 million would be the fourth largest American city, between Chicago and Houston. Every day, 35,948 people are incarcerated (source), and the only people who even bother to talk about it are considered to be on the fringe left, crazy people who can’t stop pleading for special interests.

Maybe we have more criminals who need to be locked up? It depends on how you define a criminal. Some two-thirds of people mired in the justice system (prison, probation, parole) are in for nonviolent offenses. Among federal prisoners, 91% are in for nonviolent crimes. No dictator in the world gets away with this.

And while the prison system as we know it came into existence in the early part of the 20th century, the trend toward mass imprisonment is relatively new. The numbers in prison are five times higher than in 1980, when the war on drugs really became a nationwide mania and sentencing became long and mandatory. Nearly the whole of the change is accounted for by these two facts alone. In 1980, 40,000 people were in the slammer for drug-related charges. Today, it is closer to half a million.

The statistics are not unknown. They have never been more accessible. But people hear these statistics and think: “Well, that seems like a lot of people, but hey, I’m not there and my friends and family aren’t there. Regardless, we are probably better off with too many people in jail, rather than too few. At least the streets are a bit safer than they otherwise might be. So let’s just forget about it, shall we?”

But it turns out to be very easy these days to trip over that wire that causes you to land in jail. The trouble is that you don’t know that until it happens. It could be a mistake that you or a family member made in handling too much cash. It could be a joint that someone smoked at your house party. It could be an unpaid ticket. It could be a tweet you sent that insulted a bureaucrat.

It could be the wrong download, upload or file-sharing act. Or maybe you lost your temper at the airport and said something you shouldn’t in the presence of a TSA agent. Maybe you acted on a stock tip that was slightly too revealing. Even the wrong glance at a cop could cause your life to unravel.

Any of these actions and thousands of others can cause you to become embroiled in a system you cannot control and cannot resist. You spend the night in jail. You are bailed, but there are endless legal battles ahead to get out of the thicket.

Your life suddenly becomes about keeping your freedom. You pay lawyers. You lose time from work going to hearings. You lose sleep with worry and have to take pills you never thought you would. Your finances are crushed. You can hardly think about anything else. This goes on for months and you are pretty much a wreck.

The whole thing seems crazy and preposterous. Why is the state focusing on you, rather than on real criminals? You are an easier and safer target. Plus, you broke the law. It is a dumb law and it is understandable that you broke it — and you would never do it again, even though many others who have done the same are out free — but you finally have to admit it: You are more guilty than innocent.

It comes time to plea-bargain. Your lawyers make a deal with the system. If you admit guilt, you will be let off. The sentence of 20 years, or whatever it happens to be, will likely be suspended. You agree to the deal, anything to bring an end to this hell. But something goes wrong. The judge sentences you anyway. Wait, this isn’t the way it is supposed to turn out! But now there is nothing you can do.

Then you find that the prison system is the crystallization of life under government control. Your Facebook, Twitter, email, phone number are all zapped. Freedoms of association, speech and press are entirely absent. Human rights don’t apply. The choices you can make about how to spend your time are allocated to you by wardens and at their discretion. Your person and labor are valued by no one in particular. Everything you consume — whether it is food or space — your masters regard as a favor granted.

Everyone who cares about you is outside the prison. The people on the inside do not care whether you live or die. And to your amazement and shock, you find that the prison is not filled with violent thugs, thieves and murderers. Most everyone is pretty much like you. They are people, real people with families and friends and lives, who were stopped by a cop and had forgotten to take the marijuana out of the glove box. They are people who exploded in a temporary rage at a bureaucrat. They are people who downloaded and shared the wrong files.

You discover an entire world behind walls, thousands of people just like you, and nearly all of them could be out living productive lives, caring for their families, contributing to life in their communities, living out their dreams on the outside. But here they are in this government institution — like millions of others in our time and throughout history — wasting away their lives in the name of some claim of “justice” that clearly does not exist.

The experience is enlightening and amazing. Prisoners are not who you thought they were. You want to get the news to everyone on the outside. You want to reveal this scandal to the world.

What do you say? The slogans that created this system — “the war on drugs,” “get tough on crime,” “zero tolerance,” “mandatory sentencing” — are about politics, not justice or humanitarianism, and they have nothing to do with the reality you see. It is a cruel system, completely out of control, and one with an immense human cost.

The prison system is a massive human rights violation. It has to be stopped.

But there’s a big problem: You can’t speak. You can’t act. You now know the truth, but now you also know that there is nothing you can do about it. And you also know that everyone on the outside pretty much thinks exactly how you used to think. They do not care.

  • http://www.manipulatedtrial.de Franz Kurz

    Prison and the Character of Nations
    http://www.manipulatedtrial.de/FK%20Prison%20and%20the%20Character%20of%20Nations%200108.pdf

    An uncultivated savage is never a nice inquirer into the refinements of law, by which an injury may be gradually and legally inflicted.
    (Washington Irving, 1783 – 1859, in Philip of Pokanoet)

    I have always found that mercy bears richer fruits than strict justice.
    - Abraham Lincoln

    “Knowing is not enough; we must apply. Willing is not enough. We must do.”
    Johann Wolfgang Goethe, 1749-1832

  • Nicholas Fusco

    Another great article Mr. Tucker!

    Just one question:
    aren’t we already imprisoned to some degree in this “tax farm” ;)

  • david

    Your essay hit me right in the gut. I spent a day in jail two years ago for dui. I was sixty years old and had never been arrested before. I’m still trying to get my life sorted out from that incident. I can guarantee you that the local county jail is nothing like you see in Andy of Mayberry. The paranoia among the jailers, was incredible given the innocuousness of the prisoners, most of whom weren’t much different from me, just younger. Just as an example, the toilet in each cell would take a minute or so to actually flush after the lever was pushed. Sensors in the toilet were analyzing the contents for drugs! It seemed that everything else in the prison revolved around the ongoing efforts to ferret out drugs. Everything. Another thing I learned: Whole industries have sprung up to supply state-mandated items. Things like an in-car breathalyzer rented to you at $85 a month. Over a year, that’s $1000–you could probably buy several of the devices for that. And they are mandated–the people supplying them have a steady “demand” for their product. Nice work if you can get it. Then there was the “victim panel”. This is where relatives of people killed by drunk drivers get to stand up before an audience of people convicted of dui and basically call them all attempted murderers. For this the members of the audience were privileged to pay $90 a head. I would guesstimate there were about 150 people present–$13500 in box-office receipts. Again, nice work if you can get it. Then there was the rehab program. This is where you spend two hours a week for $60 per person ($85 if they pop a urinalysis on you) discussing with a roomful of other dui’s how you can go straight. If you mind your p’s and q’s, and display the proper attitude, you might get by with about 16 weeks of this. Say about $1200 total. Again, nice work if you can get it. Not surprisingly, the number of entrepreneurs willing to provide the above “services” is proliferating. Then there was my probation officer, who worked in the public sector, unlike the above entrepreneurial element. For her managing my case file, the state charged me a mere $100 a month. Oh, I nearly forgot–there was the tow company, which charged me $225 instead of the $75 they would normally charge for the same tow. Hey, these government contracts are great, aren’t they? And finally, there’s the insurance company, which was able to more than double its premium for the five years that I’m on probation, even though I’ve never been in an at-fault accident, and my last traffic ticket was over 30 years ago. It’s now been two years and three months since my arrest, and I’m still not sure whether I ruined my life or not. I’ll let you know in a few years.

    • Chuck Culhane

      And they give out years and decades like it’s water, destroying lives inside and out. A big business. One governor left office and began an ankle monitoring company for — oh, the public good, of course, ho ho — and had lobbied legislators and courts to create a wider pool of errants to “monitor.” And all the cop toys, tazers, battering rams, etc. Beyond ominous. Excellent article by Tucker.