Does Creativity Alone Create a Special Entitlement?

A discussion we had last night on Adam V. The Man — Stefan Molyneux and I were guests — kept returning to an idea that we never really had time or space to take on directly, until it was briefly touched on at the end.

The more I think about this, much of whole question of intellectual property rights seems to turn on this idea that we own what we create. That sounds very plausible at first. When people celebrate this idea, they talk about the great sculptor who makes a majestic piece of art out of stone, the composer of a symphony, or the lowly woodworker who makes a bench in his garage. They are said to be owners of something new.

Let’s look at a more mundane example. I’m making brownies using a conventional recipe and throw in a dash of bourbon. They turn out to be great. I call them Bourbon Brownies. What do I own in this case? I own those brownies. Why? Because I made them out of ingredients that I own. Because I created them, am I entitled to speak of having created something new that I own? Perhaps in a metaphorical sense. But nothing grants me the special right to a unique ownership right to my creation that somehow allows me to extract money from anyone else in the world who adds bourbon to brownies (unless, of course, I appeal to a government bureaucracy to make it possible). I own what I own — the physical brownies I took out of the oven — and nothing more.

Let’s say the word gets out and lots of people start making this recipe. Am I violated in any sense at all? Not at all. That the word gets out takes nothing away from my right to continue to make my brownies. That’s because creativity alone generates no new and special form of property.

If I have a pile of wood, I can make a bench, burn it, pulverize it, or whatever, but there is nothing in my actions that generate a transformation of my existing rights. Only the physical object changes but no new rights are created.

What if I work for a restaurant and make the discovery that adding bourbon to brownies improves them? If I used the restaurant’s ingredients, the restaurant owns the resulting brownies. It’s the same with the carpenter. If he makes a bench as a part of a labor contract, the furniture making company owns the bench. If the carpenter takes it, he is stealing. This idea of “creativity” changes absolutely nothing about property and the rights to property.

To be sure, there is nothing wrong with a person who whistles a tune and then announces to himself: I own my new creation! That’s great. But the instant he whistles this tune on the bus and someone hears it, that new creation enters the commons. The supposed rights to the tune are reproduced, potentially unto infinity, without taking away anything at all from the initial creator of the tune.

People like to imagine that we would have something like intellectual property rights in a fully free society. Well, people are free to call things whatever they want. But there is no special category of property that is “intellectual.” Your property is what you own or acquire through trade. What you do with your property is your business. But merely announcing that what you do is “creative” grants you no special monopoly on anything.

For example: I can take off my bowtie and wear it as a scarf. Do I now own the idea of the bowtie scarf? I can claim that I do but that doesn’t somehow permit me to prevent others from tying ties up as scarves or to forcibly take a share of revenue from others who do this too.

Creativity is glorious. It is all around us. In some small measure, all of us are creating every second of our lives. You might find a new way to drive to work, a new way to pour your coffee, a special tactic for talking on your smartphone while surfing the web, a way to eat your hamburger that yields the right mix of tomatoes and onions in every bite, a new way to shave in the shower. There is, in principle, no difference between this kind of creativity and that of the sculptor or writer or composer of music. Creativity is the pith of life. But creativity alone grants no one the right to interfere with the freedom or property or others.

For more on this topic, see the new edition of Stephan Kinsella’s classic “Against Intellectual Property.” As always, it’s free to Club members.

  • The Mad, Mad War on Your Retirement

    The Mad, Mad War on Your Retirement

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Dec 17, 2014

    A new war is quietly brewing in America. A war on your retirement. Either you take steps now to protect yourself, or watch Wall Street and Big Government suck away everything you’ve worked for. Because, as Chris Campbell shows, the first shots have already been made. Learn how to protect yourself. Read on…

  • Big Pharma’s Slimy Tactics to Convince You You’re Sick

    Big Pharma’s Slimy Tactics to Convince You You’re Sick

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Dec 16, 2014

    Big Pharma is on a quiet rampage of disease-mongering. Every sniffle is an acronym. Every sneeze, the onset of some horrible disease. Chris Campbell, suffering through actual sickness, explores Big Pharma’s slimy tactics. And he digs into what you can do to protect yourself. Read on…

  • To Torture or Not to Torture… That is the Question

    To Torture or Not to Torture… That is the Question

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Dec 15, 2014

    As the CIA torture debate rages on, Chris Campbell shares his opinion on the matter. Inside, he discusses why this is not an issue of politics… why torture simply doesn’t work… and how it’s only made things worse. Read on...

  • CIA Torture Report Unveiled: Just Try Not to Puke

    CIA Torture Report Unveiled: Just Try Not to Puke

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Dec 12, 2014

    You’ve undoubtedly heard of the recently-released CIA torture reports by now. The agency instructed the agents to carry out these acts in the name of Seligman’s theory of learned helplessness. Chris Campbell sheds some light on Seligman's theory and what kind of Torture was being administered by the CIA. Read on if you can stomach it...

  • Notice: This is a Very Important Episode

    Notice: This is a Very Important Episode

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Dec 11, 2014

    Go hug your spouse and kids. Everything will be OK. Chris Campbell uncovers a close call that could’ve decimated humanity. And then, he and a colleague uncover the only secret to independent wealth. Read on…

  • shutterstock_83366287

    The Story of a Reluctant Winemaker

    Joe Maga

    by Joe Maga
    On Dec 15, 2014

    Sometimes life deals you lemons. It’s up to you to make lemonade. This month’s Insider Cellar recommended winemaker had no intention of making wine when his family settled just north of Santa Barbara. When our reluctant winemaker’s father walked his land in the early 1980s, he was probably disappointed when he discovered the soil did not have the nutrients to support his strawberry crop

     

  • You Won’t Believe These Results… and How to Buy Raw Milk

    You Won’t Believe These Results… and How to Buy Raw Milk

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Dec 10, 2014

    Welcome to extreme travel hacking. With a few simple secrets, you won’t believe how little it costs to go cross-country for five nights. Chris Campbell shows you how little he spent, and how you can do it too. Read on…

     

  • PlanesLFT

    The Secret to Great Health is Planes and Junk Food

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Dec 9, 2014

    Everything you know about what it means to be healthy is turning upside down. Chris Campbell investigates how to boost your health with planes, junk food, and by ditching chewing gum. Read on…

  • The $50k Manhunt For 100-Baggers

    The $50k Manhunt For 100-Baggers: Turn $10,000 Into $1 Million?

    Chris Mayer

    by Chris Mayer
    On Dec 8, 2014

    The elusive 100-bagger is a stock that turns a $10,000 investment into $1 million. Does it exist? Or is it some fantastical creature that people only talk about, like the unicorn or Bigfoot? Chris Mayer has launched a $50,000+ investigation to prove that not only do they exist, but he might be able to spot them out just for you. Read on…

  • “I Thought I Was Going to Die”: Crazy Confessions of a Medical Tourist

    “I Thought I Was Going to Die”: Crazy Confessions of a Medical Tourist

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Dec 5, 2014

    Right now, a generation of 78 million is getting older. And living longer than their parents. A lot longer. Meanwhile, health care costs are through the roof. Chris Campbell reports on the man who discovered the solution -- just after he thought he was going to die. Read on…

  • SHI0115

    The Only Path to the American Dream

    Ryan Cole

    by Ryan Cole
    On Dec 10, 2014

    This month, I’m going to tell you a hard truth. It’s one that Wall Street brokers and financial analysts try to hide. It’s one that most newsletter writers choose to ignore. In fact—when it comes to the financial world—this is a “secret” that everyone knows… but no one will mention.

     

  • Eye-Opening Account of Your True Net-Worth

    Eye-Opening Account of Your True Net-Worth

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Dec 4, 2014

    It’s more valuable than gold… silver… and your entire portfolio. It’s your greatest asset. Unfortunately, few Americans give it much thought until it’s too late. Until their lives turn into a total catastrophe. Chris Campbell uncovers this asset and reveals how you can shamelessly thrive amidst the sufferers. Read on…

  • Behold! The Free, Unbreakable Beast is You

    Behold! The Free, Unbreakable Beast is You

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Dec 3, 2014

    Freedom. We all want more of it… and strive to get it. But what does it really mean? And how can we actually get a piece of it for ourselves? Chris Campbell explores humanity’s quest for freedom, explains how to embrace the beast of habit, and shares his Most Obnoxiously Simple Secret for Change. Read on…

  • How to Make Enemies and Influence Buffoons

    How to Make Enemies and Influence Buffoons

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Dec 2, 2014

    We’re told change is hard. We’re told that the visionaries are “special” or “different.” We’re told that if we play by the rules we’ll be successful. We’re told a lot of things that aren’t true. In today’s Laissez Faire Today, Chris Campbell busts some of society’s biggest myths and shows that changing your life… becoming a genius… and influencing the buffoons of the world is simple. Learn how to start today. Read on…

  • 2015

    Our Quest to Make 2015 Your Best Year Yet

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Dec 1, 2014

    Thought about your New Years resolution yet? In today’s LFT, Chris Campbell will show you why change seems hard… why most New Years resolutions fail… and what you can do to push through and meet your goals. Read on…

  • TimeBomb

    Three Time Bombs in Your 401(k)

    Dave Gonigam

    by Dave Gonigam
    On Dec 4, 2014

    They lurk somewhere in everyone’s 401(k) program. Tick, tick… And it might be years before you discover them. Tick, tick… By the time you do… Kaboom! It’s too late. They’ve already blown up your retirement.

     

  • The Safest Way to Buy Illegal Drugs (Even if You Don’t Buy Drugs)

    The Safest Way to Buy Illegal Drugs (Even if You Don’t Buy Drugs)

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Nov 26, 2014

    Even if you aren’t into that sort of thing, there’s one online marketplace that makes the illicit drug industry safer for you and your family. It’s dark. It’s dodgy. It’s the underbelly of the Internet. And its making the world a better place. Read on…

  • Six Reasons to Embrace Paying More at the Pump

    Six Reasons to Embrace Paying More at the Pump

    Byron King

    by Byron King
    On Nov 25, 2014

    Gas keeps sinking lower and lower. Many pundits believe it will keep heading south. Yet our in-house oil field geologist begs to differ. Inside you’ll learn six reasons why you should soon embrace paying more at the pump. Read on…

  • Money: The Green Shapeshifter That Rules the World

    Money: The Green Shapeshifter That Rules the World

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Nov 24, 2014

    Money. It’s the most powerful word in the world. But do we really know what it is? Or how it works? In today’s Laissez Faire Today, Chris Campbell investigates these questions and more. The results, as you’ll see, are shocking. Read on…

  • You’re Just in Time: Stephen Hawking’s in the House

    You’re Just in Time: Stephen Hawking’s in the House

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Nov 21, 2014

    In today’s Laissez Faire Today, you’ll learn about one man that has already shifted the sands of time (and our understand of it)... and two innovations that are set to change the world. Brace yourself. And then read on…

  • SHI_December2014

    This Sector Is Ready to Explode 1,000% Higher

    Ryan Cole

    by Ryan Cole
    On Dec 1, 2014

    One industry is expected to grow from an estimated $77 billion sector by the end of 2014… to around $700 billion in 2024. And that, frankly, is a conservative estimate, as you’ll see below. This isn’t because of some resource boom or new discovery. This isn’t because of funny business or a trader play. This is real spending, done by real companies to combat a very real threat. It’s already an established industry but poised for exponential growth. Because the problem it combats is growing exponentially.

     

  • Modern Medicine in the Amazon Basin With Stephen Petranek

    Modern Medicine in the Amazon Basin With Stephen Petranek

    Stephen Petranek

    by Stephen Petranek
    On Nov 20, 2014

    In today’s Laissez Faire Today, you’re invited to travel deep into the Amazon basin with Stephen Petranek. Check out all the healing plants and the shamans that use them. And meet the few scientists who are taking them seriously. Read on…

  • EXPOSED: The FDA’s Pants Are Down (Quick! Look!)

    EXPOSED: The FDA’s Pants Are Down (Quick! Look!)

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Nov 19, 2014

    It’s inexcusable. It’s bad science. Terrible medicine. It’s putting your health in danger. And, unfortunately, it’s ‘business as usual.’ You won’t believe what the FDA is up to. Read on…

  • SPACE: The Final Frontier Begins

    SPACE: The Final Frontier Begins

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Nov 18, 2014

    Would you leave Earth to help colonize another planet? This might sound like an absurd question, but, according to many leaders of thought, its one we might have to confront sooner than later. Chris Campbell explores our journey from air to space, and ponders where we’re off to next. Read on…

  • Obama’s ‘Master Plan’ is Hiding in my Basement

    Obama’s ‘Master Plan’ is Hiding in my Basement

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Nov 17, 2014

    “It’s all part of Mr. Obama’s energy use micromanagement ‘master plan,’” one LFT contributor writes. “And it has set the stage for a very unpleasant scenario.” See what Obama’s up to now, and why his ‘master plan’ is hiding in Chris Campbell’s basement. Read on…

  • EightUnusual

    8 Unusual Rules for Investing

    Chris Mayer

    by Chris Mayer
    On Nov 4, 2014

    Where do great investors come from?I’m not sure what the hurdle rate for greatness is, but Guy Spier has put up impressive results. His Aquamarine Fund has returned 463% since inception in 1997, versus just 167% for the S&P 500 (a broad proxy for the market). Put another way, $1 million invested at inception is […]

     

  • Open Windows of Opportunity With Jim Rickards

    Open Windows of Opportunity With Jim Rickards

    James Rickards

    by James Rickards
    On Nov 14, 2014

    Are you a deflationist? Or an inflationist? No matter which way you believe the wind will blow, the truth is this: it’s up in the air. But, as Jim Rickards explains, there are things you can do to cover your assets, no matter which one wins the tug-of-war. Read on…

  • Mistake

    Don’t Make the Same Mistake as Hitler: One Rookie Blunder You’re Probably Guilty of

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Nov 13, 2014

    Are you making this rookie blunder? Hitler did. And he’s the last person you should be emulating. In today’s Laissez Faire Today, Chris Campbell shows you how to keep from being like Herr Wolf and start being safe and protected from your enemies. Read on…

  • The Last “Prepper” Article You’ll Ever Need

    The Last “Prepper” Article You’ll Ever Need

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Nov 12, 2014

    There’s something wrong with the “prepper” industry. Nearly all of the gurus have never been in any kind of disaster. Except for one. Chris Campbell shares one story of why you can’t count on luck to get you by, and breaks down the last prepper article you’ll ever need.

  • How to Meet Strangers and Never Feel Lonely Again

    How to Meet Strangers and Never Feel Lonely Again

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Nov 11, 2014

    All social animals are wired to thrive with social connections -- and wither away without them. Chris Campbell investigates the challenges of moving to a new place… meeting new people… and how to pull yourself out of a rut if you’re feeling lonely. Read on…

  • SHI_November2014

    A Double-Digit Winner That’s Attacking America’s No. 1 Killer

    Ryan Cole

    by Ryan Cole
    On Nov 1, 2014

    I made a choice five months ago. And that choice has saved my life. This wasn’t some instantaneous decision, with danger near. It wasn’t some great “eureka” moment, either. There probably isn’t a person out there who would question what I did. In fact, more and more people are making the exact same choice every day. And each one does it to the sound of applause.

     

  • Revealed: The Ancient “Elixir for Long Life”

    Revealed: The Ancient “Elixir for Long Life”

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Nov 10, 2014

    Laissez Faire’s FREE Tip of the Day: Learn how to make a cheap bottle of wine taste like it came from upper crust. Just don’t tell the wine snobs how you did it. Read on…

  • If You Vote, You Have No Right to Complain: 11 Things to Do Instead

    If You Vote, You Have No Right to Complain: 11 Things to Do Instead

    Chris Campbell

    by Chris Campbell
    On Nov 7, 2014

    You’ve heard it before: “If you don’t vote, you have no right to complain.” But is it true? Chris Campbell debunks this fallacy. In fact, “If you vote,” he says, “you have no right to complain.” Read on…